How Wall Street Bonuses Impact Spousal Maintenance and Alimony in NY
In my experience, most people involved in a high-asset divorce first consider the obvious—dividing real estate and other property, calculating spousal maintenance (commonly known as alimony), and protecting one’s business interests. Many of my clients understand the high stakes and comprehensive nature of an Action for Divorce. They build a working understanding of how New York law generally handles these issues, but divorce law offers no shortage of complexity.
Even savvy financial professionals who spend significant time learning the finer details of divorce proceedings will, in my experience, encounter aspects that confound them. One of those common pain points is: How do spouses—and New York law—address bonuses within the broader context of divorce proceedings?
Pertinent questions include:
- Does New York law consider bonuses to be “marital property” (and, if so, when do they stop being marital property)?
- How does the often unpredictable nature of Wall Street bonuses reflect in a marital settlement agreement?
- Do deferred bonuses fall within or outside the duration of the marital economic partnership?
- How can spouses address both discretionary and non-discretionary bonuses in a manner conducive to privacy, civility, and mutual trust while minimizing the need for future modifications of the agreement?
Wall Street bonuses are proof that wealth is complex. Yet, complex marital settlement discussions and agreements—including those that account for bonus compensation—can remain dignified. We help clients and their spouses divorce with dignity. This requires confidence from both sides that a settlement is fair, down to the finest detail of how bonuses will be divided or treated as separate property.
Reach out to our team at Miller Law Group to discuss your circumstances, including any particular bonuses and other concerns that we can address. I am available online and by phone at (914) 768-7765 when you are ready to schedule your consultation.
Yes, Variable Compensation Like Bonuses Complicates the Spousal Maintenance Discussion (and Divorces More Broadly)
Most spouses whose partners are high earners, particularly in the financial sector, know that bonuses are frequently conditional and variable. This mutual understanding informs divorce proceedings, but challenges and complications remain.
I am going to delve into the finer details of how we (in accordance with New York law) address bonus-related issues for our clients. First, know that bonuses can be inherently complicating factors in these proceedings because:
- Investment bankers’ and executives’ bonuses often depend on personal and organizational performance over the prior year, causing variance that clashes with the fixed nature of spousal maintenance distribution.
- Base pay, which is the more predictable form of compensation for bankers and executives, can prove to be a modest portion of total annual income for high-earners—further obscuring the appropriate calculation of spousal maintenance.
- Restricted Stock Units (RSUs) and other forms of deferred compensation, extremely common on Wall Street, introduce questions about the definition of marital property, how to handle assets with an indeterminate future value, and tax considerations.
- Should a spouse’s professional circumstances change, their bonuses and total income may be impacted substantially—a development directly impacting spousal maintenance.
Our collaborative approach resonates with our clients. Their goal is to reach mutual understanding, not to become mired in litigation. This approach demands that we address these challenges head-on and one by one.
Once we clarify the law as it applies to this particular case and establish mutually agreed-upon valuations (perhaps with assistance from a forensic accountant or compensation specialist), a resolution is no longer far off.
I’ve seen the effectiveness of this step-by-step approach time and again as a high-net-worth divorce attorney. Let’s stick with what works, then, by addressing the “bonus” conversation one critical point at a time.
Are Bonuses Marital Property? Timing Is Everything.
You probably know this, but marital property (as opposed to separate property) is the property that gets divided “equitably” in divorce proceedings, per New York law. The line between “mine” and “ours” runs between marital and separate property. It’s no surprise that most clients’ handful of pressing questions includes this one.
To determine whether some or all of a bonus qualifies as marital property, we must recognize that:
- In general, property acquired after filing a divorce summons with the County Clerk (the Date of Commencement) is no longer marital property
- For legal purposes, bonuses serve two primary purposes: 1) Compensating the recipient for past performance, 2) Incentivizing the recipient to remain as an employee or fulfill some other future service (in some cases, the bonus serves both ends)
If a bonus is deemed to be compensation for work done while the recipient was married (i.e., compensation), it is generally considered marital property. If a bonus is deemed an incentive for future action or services, it may not be deemed marital property (depending on the date of the divorce filing).
How Does This Apply to Unvested Stock Options?
The 1997 ruling in DeJesus v. DeJesus provides a legal framework for addressing unvested stock options during divorce proceedings. Courts have since applied the ruling to RSUs. We call these frameworks “time rules.”
The formulaic “time rule” for unvested bonuses that qualify as compensation is:
- The numerator is the time from the later of the beginning of the titled spouse’s employment with the issuing company or the beginning of the marriage, until the date of the grant
- The denominator is the time from the beginning of the titled spouse’s employment until the date of the grant
The “time rule” for unvested bonuses that qualify as future incentive is:
- The numerator is the time elapsed from the date of the stock grant to the date the matrimonial action began
- The denominator is the time elapsed from the date of the stock grant through the vesting/exercisable date
These are frameworks, not to be mistaken as the proper mode of resolution in every divorce. Such frameworks must be molded to the distinct details of each marriage, and that is where my team plays a critical, facilitative role.
How Bonuses Enter the Maintenance Formula
New York determines spousal maintenance payments formulaically for both:
- Temporary maintenance (or pendente lite support): Detailed in Domestic Relations Law Section 236(B)(5-a), this form of maintenance covers the period when the maintenance is first ordered through the resolution of divorce proceedings.
- Post-divorce maintenance: This maintenance takes effect after the divorce judgment is entered. This is, for most, the far more consequential of the two forms of spousal maintenance, and its effective period depends on case-specific considerations including the duration of the marriage.
In both cases, a spouse’s income, defined in the Child Support Standards Act (CSSA) as gross income minus FICA and NYC/Yonkers taxes, primarily determines the amount of monthly spousal maintenance payments. Before I share these formulas and related caveats, I want to clarify that a bonus divided as marital property is deducted from the payor’s income for the purposes of calculating monthly maintenance payments—a preventative against double counting.
Generally speaking, it’s true that:
- A bonus earned during the marriage can be qualified as marital property
- A bonus earned after the date the divorce summons was filed can be counted as separate income, meaning it may be included in the maintenance formula
Within the maintenance formula(s), bonuses not divided as marital property generally count towards income as the CSSA defines above. Let’s examine those formulas.
The Maintenance Formula When Child Support Is Paid
When a payor is also responsible for providing child support, their monthly spousal maintenance obligation will be calculated by whichever of these formulas produces the lesser amount:
- Calculation 1: 20% of the payor’s income minus 25% of the payee’s income
- Calculation 2: 40% of the spouses’ combined income minus the payee’s total income
New York Courts have “broad discretion to impute income,” meaning to assign income that a spouse didn’t earn but could and should have earned. Just because actual income, before any imputed income, is lower in a single year than in prior years does not mean the court will use that lower-income year figure to calculate maintenance. The reverse is also true, that higher income in a single year won’t necessarily make it an appropriate anchor for maintenance calculations. A single year’s W-2 counting an unusually large bonus is not, in most cases, an appropriate anchor for spousal maintenance calculations. Generally, courts (and attorneys like myself) consider a three-to-five-year window of financials, including bonus payments, to identify reasonable averages and ensure financial obligations are fair and sustainable.
Along with neutral financial experts, we review a broad range of current and historical income and asset records, discuss both spouses’ professional and financial circumstances honestly, and work to identify a fair and appropriate spousal maintenance figure.
The Maintenance Formula Without Child Support
When divorces do not involve child support, the lesser sum produced by the following two formulas generally dictates the monthly maintenance payment:
- Calculation 1: 30% of the payor’s income minus 20% of payee’s income
- Calculation 2: 40% of the spouses’ combined income minus the payee’s total income
New York’s statutory income cap of $241,000 (as of 2026) is an important consideration for many clients who work in the financial sector and will be responsible for monthly alimony payments.
Some portion of Wall Street bonuses often pushes gross income above this cap, in which case we must determine whether (or how much) income above the cap should be counted toward the monthly maintenance payment. The standard of living during a marriage, the length of the marriage, and the payee’s financial circumstances are among the considerations we weigh when seeking a mutually acceptable maintenance arrangement.
Handling Declared-but-Unpaid and Deferred Bonuses
It’s a realistic scenario: An employer declares annual bonuses in December of a given year. An executive files for divorce after learning their bonus amount, but before the bonus is disbursed in the early months of the following year.
The rule of thumb is that, if the bonus was earned during the marriage, that bonus is generally marital property subject to division. This is true even though the bonus is paid after the Date of Commencement.
I’ve also encountered cases where the payor’s bonus reflects services performed both during the marriage and after the divorce filing. Here, we may rely on the aforementioned DeJesus time rules, applying a pro-rata formula to define the marital property portion of the bonus from the portion that qualifies as separate property. As I mentioned earlier, these time rules are also the primary mechanism for factoring deferred bonuses into New York divorce proceedings.
Percentage-Based Support for Discretionary Bonuses
In my experience, spouses involved in high-asset New York divorces mutually recognize that:
- Bonuses are a source of income (and often a substantial one) that must be factored into spousal maintenance and broader divorce proceedings
- Discretionary bonuses also fluctuate
Bonuses’ fluctuations make it difficult, if not impossible, to rely on a static spousal maintenance schedule. To solve this issue, we frequently rely on a model in which:
- A designated percentage of the payor’s base salary (guaranteed so long as they remain employed) covers the monthly spousal maintenance payment
- If and when the payor receives a discretionary bonus, the payee receives an agreed-upon percentage of the bonus (referred to as “true-up” adjustment payments)
- Agreed-upon caps and tiered percentages protect the payor from extraordinary outgoing payments that might be deemed unreasonable or contrary to the spirit of the agreement
These agreements also include safeguards against double-counting and give due attention to tax considerations.
Why Resolving Bonus Disputes Through Mediation Just Makes Sense in High-Asset Divorces
Most clients who approach my team don’t want a court ruling to define their foreseeable future. They know that a mutual agreement is possible. They also recognize the financial and legal complexity native to divorces in general, and high-asset divorces in particular. In short, they want the financial clarity that precedes every sustainable Marital Settlement Agreement.
Trust me when I say that divorce does not have to be bitter or prolonged. Mediation is the pathway for those who want to maintain dignity and civility through clarity and collaboration, despite the circumstances that led them to this point.
New York statutes grant you the right to “voluntarily enter into agreements or stipulations” that “deviate from the presumptive award of temporary maintenance.” The same is true for post-divorce maintenance, that you may voluntarily enter into agreements to deviate from the post-divorce maintenance guideline. In other words, you can decide what is best for you and your spouse, and we can help.
The Key Ingredient in Dignified Divorces? It’s the Right Guidance. Talk to a NY Executive-Divorce Attorney Today.
Katherine Eisold Miller and the team at Miller Law Group strongly believe the courtroom is not the right environment for any divorce, especially those involving complex financial assets. We reject the hostility too common in these proceedings and instead rely on collaborative negotiation to produce efficient, mutually acceptable resolutions.
We serve clients throughout New York and Connecticut, with offices in Westchester, Manhattan, and Greenwich. If you live in one of these areas, I encourage you to connect with us online or call me at (914) 768-7766 when you are ready to talk about divorcing with dignity.
For my avid readers, consider downloading the Restricted Stock Units in Divorce eBook. A knowledgeable client is often a credit to their own cause, and I hope the book will strengthen the foundation we will mediate upon.
Frequently Asked Questions
I want to share a few questions and concise answers that come up frequently during consultations and client meetings.
Is my year-end bonus considered marital property in New York?
Bonuses earned during marriage are generally designated as marital property—yes, even if a bonus is paid after the County Clerk receives the divorce summons.
Bonuses earned after the Date of Commencement (i.e., the formal filing of divorce papers) are generally counted towards gross income and factored into the calculation of spousal maintenance.
Questions about whether a bonus corresponds to past services or, instead, serves as an incentive for some future action (like remaining with the employer) can complicate this matter.
How are bonuses factored into spousal maintenance calculations?
Bonuses that are not divided as marital property are generally treated as gross income. In calculating monthly maintenance payments, New York Courts generally subtract a percentage of the payee’s gross income from a percentage of the payor’s gross income.
We must consider New York’s 2026 statutory income cap of $241,000, which many who receive Wall Street bonuses reach (especially once those bonuses are included in the gross income calculation). My team and I help spouses determine whether income beyond this cap should be included in the monthly maintenance calculation.
These calculations, and the tailored financial agreements that these calculations serve as launching pads for, must reflect the variable nature of bonuses for finance professionals. Agreements that allow for true-up adjustment payments are one way we account for this variability.
What happens with bonuses that are declared but not yet paid?
When defining marital property versus separate property and calculating monthly maintenance, bonuses are categorized based on when they were earned, not when they were paid.
How do courts handle unpredictable or discretionary bonuses?
Courts, mediators, and financial experts must consider several years’ worth of financial information. Because bonuses are particularly prone to fluctuation, they can be misleading when viewed in isolation. We are thorough in our financial analyses, trusting multi-year averages over any particular bonus that might be an outlier.
We also utilize the aforementioned true-up adjustment payments. By anchoring the base maintenance payments to the payor’s base salary, then disbursing a fair percentage of any paid bonuses from the payor to the payee, we can account for variable bonuses without distressing the payor in times of lesser (or non-existent) bonuses.
The
Emotionally
Savvy Divorce
Katherine E. Miller, JD
Author
pre order now


